Allah only desires to keep away the uncleanness from you, O people of the House! and to purify you a (thorough) purifying. [Holy Quran 33:33]

Conversation between Imam Ali(as) and Abu Bakr(la)

 

Imam Ali(as): Have you read the book of Allah(swt)?

 

Abu Bakr(la): Yes.

 

Imam Ali(as): The Ayat of Tatheer (i.e. 33:33) has been send down in our praise or in the praise of  others?

 

Abu Bakr(la): Yes, in Your praise.

 

Imam Ali(as): If a witness, witnesses against Janabe Fatima(sa) regarding a bad thing, what will you do in that case?

 

Abu Bakr(la): I will apply the Islamic Had on her(sa) just like its done for other muslim women.

 

Imam Ali(as): In that case you will be among the Kaafir in the sight of Allah(swt).

 

Abu Bakr(la): No.

 

Imam Ali(as): Because in this case you rejected the declaration of Allah(swt) regarding the Purity of Janabe Fatima(sa) , accepting  the declaration of the common people.

 

[ Ref: Ihtijaaj-e-Tabarisi Vol 1 , Pg: 120 ]

 

So it can be concluded that when we come across any incident which states that a

wrong deed ( Gunah ) has been committed by any of the MASOOMS (those included in Aayate Tatheer), and if we accept it , then as per the above Proof given by Imam Ali(as) we will become a KAFIR!!!!!!!!!!!